…and quite frankly, that’s what it is.
Everyone is talking about Fifty Shades of Grey. I may be a little late to weigh in on this. I put off reading the book for a long time – I knew it was going to be something that I just don’t read.

But, read it I did.
And alas, I feel as though I need to go to confession…I’m not Catholic BTW…it’s a quite rueful read.
Don’t bother.
Here’s my take. Unrealistic, pornographic, unrealistic, silly, over done, porn, and did I mention unrealistic!
The story of a control freak, heavy on the freak, who’s into bondage or in street language, BDSM, and his newest ‘sub’, it takes a young woman from virginity to freaky sex at warp speed. The main character other the Christian Grey (I am sure the name alone was intentionally chosen to insult), is Anastasia Steel (again, the name was intentional), a graduating senior at a Washington College, who meets Mr. Grey serendipitously; her room mate is too ill to make an appointment to interview him. As fate would have it, he’s smitten, and commits to make her his love slave on the spot.
She is of course not aware of this, and falls prey to Grey in an over the top manner. Really, really, really over the top!
She also talks to herself waaaaaaaay too much!
And her ‘inner goddess’ talks to her waaaaaaaay too much too!
Really, you want to slap them both!
It has been on the best seller list for weeks. The largest segment of purchasers: TEENAGE GIRLS!!!!
The teen rush has been spurred on by pictures like this…

Ms. Gomez shouldn’t be reading this book, and this picture alone has sold millions. I’m sure Ms. James, the author nearly peed herself with joy when she saw it! The only thing that could make it sell more is for Michelle Obama and Oprah to do an audio book!
This is not a book for teens. The topic alone is adult – ONLY, and barely that.
Frankly, raised by wolves comes to mind. Where are the parents?
I’m not even sure it’s a book for adults!
It’s considered a romance novel. Really? The last romance novel I read was Falcounhurst Something or Other about a hundred years ago. Romance novels consist of heaving breasts, turgid flesh, and trembling thighs. This book consists of whips, chains, and terms I’m too prudish to mention…and THAT’S A STATEMENT RIGHT THERE!
As to the writing, it’s just not all that good. Now, it’s not just Heather Graham bad, it’s Danielle Steel bad!! It’s just not good writing. Think about it, D.H. Lawrence told a love story with over the top sex, yes, it was banned, and yes, it was provocative, but at least it was real literature.
This is not.
It’s smut.
To take a line from Dorothy Parker, “…this is a novel that should not be tossed aside lightly, it should be hurled with great force…”
Frankly, I think the author, Ms. E. L. James, deserves a good spanking!!


11 comments
Comment by Jenny (your lovely niece) on July 25, 2012 at 8:18 am
Not gonna read it! Thanks for reminding me why.
Comment by Kassie on July 25, 2012 at 10:38 am
Another home run, UP! = ) I refuse to read it. Once I heard that the writing was horribly conceived, I didn’t give it a second thought. I’ve never been one for hype. Even the best of subjects can be ruined by bad writing and every turn of the page equates to torture for the “editorially-minded”. Where’s the fun in that?
Comment by Susan Richardson Keyes on July 25, 2012 at 10:38 am
Very good my friend, very good! I like the “hurled with great force” quote.
Comment by Ellen Brill on July 25, 2012 at 10:39 am
Ha….I simply don’t get it and won’t read it. Loved the review!
Comment by Dallas on July 25, 2012 at 10:49 am
Best closing line ever!!
Comment by Diane on July 25, 2012 at 12:07 pm
You have done a public service here!
Comment by Millionaire Mike on July 25, 2012 at 5:37 pm
Excellent!
Comment by Joe and Sheri on July 25, 2012 at 5:40 pm
I know you well enough to just take your word for it. I just saw on Facebook a woman asked her husband to bring her 50 shades of grey and he brought her home paint colors !!!
I have read two of the Girl With The Dragon Tatoo and think that’s as racy as I want to get and you know me well enough to know how backward I am!! Love ya, Sheri
Comment by nell on July 26, 2012 at 12:47 am
Nah… You don’t want to mention ‘spanking’ to the author. That might prompt 51 shades of something or other.
Very well put!
Comment by Goodness and Grit on July 29, 2012 at 7:11 pm
Hahaha!
I have been toying with the idea of putting this one on my book club’s reading list.
Why? It’s a social group and most meet up for the social, skipping the read. I was thinking if it were smutty enough every one would read it making for record discussion!
But your review smacked me back to reality.
I am currently enjoying Follett’s The Fall of Giants.
Klem,
Kimberly
Comment by Nola Thacker on August 3, 2012 at 6:36 am
I love your book reviews!
n